Host a Freakishly Frugal Halloween Party

Mama Say What?! is the new name for Thrifty Guardian.

My son’s birthday falls near Halloween, so we’ve gotten very good at the groove of spooktacular parties, and while throwing Halloween parties (or any parties, for that matter) can be as elaborate as you want it to be, we’ve mastered the cheap-but-awesome Halloween bash.

Halloween Party Ideas on a Budget

If you’re looking to have a spooky shindig of your own without murdering your budget, here are some ideas we’ve put into practice that are thrifty on money but big on fun.

Be Creative in Costuming

I’m a big fan of going through the post-Halloween sales at stores, getting an idea of what my kids might like to wear down the road. We picked up 3 $40 costumes at Toys R Us last year for less than $10 each on Halloween, and that’s what the kids are wearing this year (be on the lookout for the cutest Pikachu ever!!)

Hand painted Pikachu onesie that says I Choose You

Update: Heh, okay, so maybe Toys-R-Us is no longer an option (RIP), but plenty of stores sell their costumes on clearance after Halloween. Even if you don’t know what your child might want to be, if the costumes are cheap enough, they’re worth the gamble! You can always resell them if your child decides he no longer wants to be a Dinosaur and is instead a cowboy from outer space!

For the adults, last year, we were all about punny costume ideas. My husband wore a wool pig hat and pinned a blanket over his shoulders, and I took a yellow shirt, made rings of black duct tape around it, and pinned on some felt letters. Adding an antennae hair band and black pants completed my costume. Do you get it? Heh not all our guests did, but I still stand by us being oh-so-punny…

In all honesty, cheap and clever costumes always win the day over-elaborate, expensive, pre-made costumes from stores that cost an arm and a leg and are usually pretty hideous. Though, this year, I do want us to go as Malcolm Reynolds and Inara… ideas on doing that are most definitely welcome!

A Little Decoration Can Make a Big Impact

Black everywhere is an excellent way to increase the spooky mood and save on pre-made Halloween props. A big, black sheet over the couch will help protect it from your party guests while also helping to darken the room and elevate the atmosphere. In addition, taking an old sheet and shredding it or cutting ragged holes in it and using it as a room divider or pinning it up over an entranceway is a creepy-but-cheap addition to your party’s décor.

One of my favorite cheap decorating centerpieces is buying a large bag of spiderwebs sold around this time of year. One big bag will usually run about $3 or less. If you take your time to stretch it well, finding lots of edges and nooks to catch it on, it can fill a room and make an impressive display for your party.

Lighting is also your friend because you can alter it magnificently with little expense or difficulty. Repurposing Christmas lights but filtering them with gauze or wrapping them around a bowl of red punch is a great way to add a spooky effect to what you already have. Dying cheesecloth black or using black or red tissue paper and covering light fixtures (ones that use cool-touch bulbs, mind you!) adds a touch of creep for super cheap!

Decorating for Halloween on a Budget

August and September are great for garage sales, as it’s typically cooling off and hopefully drying out. This is also a great time to snag costumes, decorations, and other things to repurpose for Halloween concepts. We’ve picked up a lot of our favorite decorations from garage sales for .25 cents to $1, everything from serving platters and pumpkin buckets to big, showy, light-up decorations.

On the other end of that spectrum, having your garage sale and selling things like costumes around this time of year will help you get some extra spending money to update your Hallo-wardrobe or decoration supply for the upcoming season.

Dollar Store Halloween Wreath

I created a super cute moon-shaped Halloween Wreath using all dollar store supplies this year! This wreath only cost me $5 and it glows in the dark. I love it!! You could truly lose yourself in looking up dollar-store Halloween décor ideas, but let’s face it – it’s a lot of fun and a great way to do Halloween on a budget!

Halloween Window Rainbow Clings

I’m also a big fan of these Halloween Window Rainbow Clings – you can get a set of 16 for less than $14!! Not only are they super fun – kids and ads will love them – but these Halloween window rainbow clings are suncatcher stickers. When light shines through, you’ll see a beautiful rainbow cast through. Similar to when light reflects through a prism! I love using these on my car windows, it always brings a smile to my kids’ faces as they look for the rainbows at the stoplights. If you’re throwing a frugal Halloween party, these are also perfect to include in goody bags.

Halloween Suncatcher Stickers - Halloween Window Rainbow Clings

Halloween Party Food Ideas

Last year we picked up five skull goblets from the dollar store for $5 total and then got a big bag of apples, some chocolate chips, some coconut flakes, some peanuts, and some caramel from Aldi, all together for under $10.

Make a Caramel Apple Bar

We crushed the peanuts and sliced the apples, set each goblet out full of toppings, and had a caramel apple bar with plenty to go around. It was a huge hit, and for about $15, of which $5 will stick around in the form of the goblets, which we kept to use again.

red plastic skull filled with colorful chocolate candies

Deviled Egg “Pumpkins”

I also make deviled eggs and cut black olives to look like spiders or use green onion to make “pumpkins” – it’s time-consuming. However, the effect is adorably spooky and freakishly frugal!

platter of deviled eggs filled with orange filling and topped with green onion pieces to look like pumpkins

Broiling hot dogs and adding a sliver of onion as a fingernail, wrap them in string cheese to make mummies, or make a huge batch of chocolate pudding, add a layer of crumbled-up Oreo-like cookies, and add some gummy worms and cookie “tombstones” for a spooky-yet-tasty graveyard as a centerpiece to your food table.

The effort shows through more than money spent, and especially children will get a kick out of tasty treats presented in a horrific but friendly fashion.

halloween party ideas

Little Details Make a Big Picture

  • Rent a spooky movie and have it playing in the background.
  • Ask everyone to come in costume – this increases the mood and engagement of your guests!
  • Throw the party in the middle of the afternoon or later in the evening. This alleviates your need to provide an actual meal rather than snacks.
  • Make it BYOB, or make a big bowl of witches brew for the adults, using hard liquor. This will be my first Halloween not pregnant or nursing in four years, so you can bet we’ll be making a fantastically frugal “adult drink”! You won’t need expensive alcohol if it’s mixed with punch, and this will save you significant money over beer or wine for a large crowd.
  • Make it a spooky potluck, offer a link to ghoulish treat ideas in your email or Facebook invite (also saving you money on postage), and have a contest for the spookiest dish. A little competition is often a great motivator!

Utilizing these ideas allows you to have a fantastic Halloween party without straining your budget. In addition, if you’re a Halloween season fanatic like me, picking up decorations or party favors when they’re on clearance or at garage sales ensures you have to spend less the following year, as you’ll already have non-perishables covered.

Do you have plans yet for Halloween? I’d love to hear about your costume ideas in the comments section!

More From Mama Say What?!

10 of the Best Apps That Pay You Money in 2023

Credit Card Debt Forgiveness: Key Considerations for Families

The post Host a Freakishly Frugal Halloween Party first appeared on Mama Say What?!

Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Yuganov Konstantin

How to throw a great Halloween party for less than $50! Frugal Halloween, cheap Halloween, Halloween party ideas, Halloween treats


+ posts

Amy Ives is a vibrant and resourceful writer known for her engaging home hacks, travel insights, and money-saving tips. With a knack for turning everyday challenges into fun, practical solutions, Amy's articles are a go-to for readers seeking clever tricks and life-enhancing advice.