Tomato Substitute In Chili: Top 5 Best Choices

Most people think of chili as a beef-based dish, but it can also be made with other meats or no meat at all.

And tomatoes are a staple in chili as well. They are typically used for flavor. But what if you don’t have any? Is there an easy substitute for it?

Yes, there are.

I have compiled some ideas on what to use if you don’t have tomatoes available.

Let’s check them out in this post.

Read more: What To Do With Leftover Apple Cider?

Best tomato substitutes in chili

tomato substitute in chili


Pumpkin is a good alternative to tomatoes in chili.

It is healthy and safe for most people. But some people may have allergies after eating pumpkin, and it can also make you go to the bathroom more often.

This effect can harm people on certain medicines, even though pumpkin is healthy. Pumpkin-based junk food contains a lot of sugar, which does not have the same health benefits as just eating the fruit.


A carrot can be a good substitute for tomatoes in chili. Carrots also have lycopene which helps prevent heart disease. They make your immune system stronger and they help with constipation because of their fiber content.

Carrots can help you if you have diabetes. Carrots are good for keeping blood sugar levels under control and they contain Vitamin A and beta-carotene, which might help lower your chance of getting diabetes.

They also provide calcium and vitamin K, which we need for strong bones.


A great substitute for tomatoes in chili is zucchini. Zucchini is a vegetable that has lots of vitamins and minerals, as well as plant compounds.

This fruit may offer many health benefits from digestion to a lower risk of heart disease. You can try adding this soft, mild fruit to your diet today.

Bell peppers

Bell peppers are good for your health. And they also make great alternatives to tomatoes in this situation.

They give you vitamins and antioxidants, such as vitamin C and carotenoids. This is important because it will make your eyes better and reduce the risk of some types of chronic diseases. So eat bell peppers.


Corn is good for you because it has vitamin C. That helps your cells from being damaged and from getting diseases like cancer or heart disease. Corn also has carotenoids, which are good for your eyes and help with cataracts.

You can try switching tomatoes with corn for your next chili dish.

Do tomatoes belong in chili?

Yes, tomatoes often go in chili. It can be spicy, but it is good.

Why do you put tomato paste in chili?

Tomato paste gives flavor to chili. It is one of the main ingredients in this recipe and it helps make the chili taste good.

Do you peel tomatoes for chili?

No need for that, I will just add the tomato puree to my chili.

The tomatoes will break down when you cook them, so it does not take time to peel or dice them. But if you prefer skinned and diced tomatoes, remove the peel, stem, and seeds and dice them.

What can replace tomatoes in chili?

In chili, you can try replacing tomatoes with crushed tomatoes. To make this, mix beef bouillon powder and paprika. Then add 75% of the water recommended on the label. Cook this mixture in a pot and add red bell peppers if you want to.

What can I use in place of tomato sauce in chili?

Tomato paste. It’s a very good alternative to tomato sauce. You should mix together tomato paste and water with a 1:1 ratio until your mixture is well blended.

Can you put too much tomato paste in chili?

Yes, it is possible. If you accidentally add too much tomato paste to your dish, try adding water and salt. You can also try using some seasonings like oregano, rosemary, pepper, or basil.

Can I use tomato paste instead of tomato sauce in chili?

Yes, you can try using tomato paste instead of sauce. It is like tomato sauce, but it is very concentrated.

Will tomato paste thicken chili?

The tomato paste will make your chili thicker. Put 1 small can of tomato paste in for the last 30 minutes while you are cooking. Then let it simmer until it is thick.

I have no tomato paste for chili, what can I do?

If tomato paste is not an option for your chili, use tomato sauce or puree. The ratio should be 1:3. That means 1 tomato paste tablespoon for 3 tomato sauce (or puree) tablespoons.

Can I use fresh tomatoes instead of canned ones in chili?

You can. You need to chop your fresh tomatoes in 2 cups or 14.5 ounces for one can of diced tomatoes in the recipe.

If the recipe calls for whole canned tomatoes, you will need to peel them first and if they call for canned tomato puree, you will need to cook and puree them yourself or stick with using the canned ones.

What’s the best way to cut tomatoes for chili?

Here is a great video tutorial you should watch:

What tomato type is best for chili?

Roma tomatoes are best for chili. They break down well in slow-cooking dishes like chili because they take a long time to stew and break down.

Can you use Roma tomatoes in chili?

Yes, you ou can use Roma tomatoes for chili.

They are different than canned tomatoes, but people who know a lot about chili say it is worth the extra time to cook them.

To make your chili, cut up an onion and some of the fresh Roma tomatoes. Add tomato paste, kidney beans, and the rest of the fresh Roma tomatoes to your meat and stir it all together.

Can crushed tomatoes be substituted for diced tomatoes in chili?

Yes. But you will need to increase the cooking time. You could also food-processing diced tomatoes and add a little tomato paste to them for a closer result.

Can I switch tomato sauce for ketchup in chili?

Yes, you can use ketchup instead of tomato sauce, but only if it is not the main ingredient. The recipe will taste different because ketchup has sugar and vinegar in it, while tomato sauce does not.

Replace tomato sauce with ketchup at a 1 to 1 ratio.


There you have them. These are the top 5 best substitutes for tomatoes in chili you should know about:

  • Pumpkin
  • Carrots
  • Zucchini
  • Bell peppers
  • Corn

Whether it’s pumpkin or carrots, zucchini or bell peppers, corn, or other vegetables- these ingredients should help make your chili even more delicious and flavorful than before.

+ posts