Female martial artists have raised concerns over the growing presence of trans women athletes in women’s categories within the North American Grappling Association (NAGA).
Female Fighters Are Unprepared
NAGA, a leading submission grappling association, has been criticized for matching female athletes against trans women.
Female fighters say they arrive at matches unprepared for the challenges posed by male opponents.
NAGA, however, claims that athletes are informed of their competitors’ status before a match-up and provides alternative divisions.
Competing Against Trans Women
One of the primary concerns expressed by female martial artists is the lack of awareness when competing against trans women.
These athletes, while transitioning or identifying as women, often possess physical advantages in terms of strength and size.
A Controversial Battleground
The NAGA has facilitated standards and organized tournaments across various martial arts disciplines, including Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.
Initially, the organization provided separate competition categories for males and females, allowing fair and safe participation.
The Taelor Moore Incident
The controversy gained widespread attention following an incident involving Taelor Moore, a female Brazilian jiu-jitsu athlete.
Moore unwittingly competed against James “Alice” McPike, a trans female.
The Shocking Weight Difference
Taelor Moore posted a clip of her fight against James “Alice” McPike on her Instagram and noted there was a 65 lbs weight difference between them.
NAGA’s Response and Policy Clarification
In response to the growing debate, NAGA issued a statement clarifying its policies regarding the inclusion of trans women in women’s categories.
According to NAGA, female athletes are given a choice when they learn that their competitors are transgender.
They can either compete in a separate division, including transgender females or opt-out.
Inadequate Enforcement of Policies
Despite NAGA’s claim to have policies in place, there are concerns that the enforcement of these policies remains inadequate.
Several female martial artists have reported being matched against trans women without prior notification, leaving them unprepared and uncomfortable.
Voices From the Arena: Real-Life Experiences
Professional martial artists, including Jayden Alexander and Ansleigh Wilk, have shared their firsthand experiences of competing against male opponents in NAGA tournaments.
Physical Disparities Are Making Them Uncomfortable
Their accounts reveal the shock and discomfort they felt upon realizing their opponents’ gender identity and the resulting physical disparities.
A Strength Advantage
One common theme expressed by female fighters is the significant strength advantage exhibited by male competitors.
The difference in physical power between men and women can be a substantial challenge for female martial artists.
The Toll on Female Fighters
Jayden Alexander, a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu blue belt, described the toll the match took on her body.
The difference in strength and technique became apparent during her contest with Cordelia Gregory, leaving her with cramping forearms and a deep emotional impact.
Ansleigh Wilk, a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu brown belt and coach, recounted her experience of fighting Cordelia Gregory without prior notification.
“I honestly never thought this would actually happen in a contact sport, especially not MY contact sport,” she said.
The Fear of Labeling and Silencing
Female athletes like Ansleigh Wilk stress that many women are hesitant to voice their concerns about this matter.
The fear of being labeled as bigots or transphobic has silenced athletes who should be able to openly discuss their experiences.
The Potential Demise of Women’s Sports
Female fighters express deep concerns that the inclusion of male fighters in women’s categories may lead to the eventual demise of women’s sports.
Fear of Losing Opportunities
There is a real fear that medals, belts, records, and opportunities for female fighters may be compromised, affecting the future of women’s sports.
She Says Organizations Should Be Held Accountable
Marshi Smith, the co-founder of the Independent Council on Women’s Sports (ICONS), has been a vocal advocate on this issue.
She said that organizations and teams encouraging the participation of trans women in women’s categories should be held accountable.
Female Fighters’ Self-Exclusion
The inclusion of trans women has led many female fighters to self-exclude from competitions.
Female Fighters Back Out of Competitions
Frustrated by the lack of enforcement of policies and communication, female fighters have chosen not to participate to avoid potential mismatches.
Lodging Formal Complaints
Female athletes have attempted to formally lodge complaints and address their concerns, but many have faced dismissive responses.
They believe it is crucial for organizations to address these issues transparently and safeguard the rights and safety of female athletes.
Fourth-Grader Identifies Self as “Genderqueer Lesbian” – Prepare to Be Astonished by How This Mother Is Navigating the Situation
In a heartfelt plea during a recent Wilson County School Board meeting in Tennessee, Lindsey Patrick-Wright, a concerned mother, exposed the cruel insults hurled at her sixth-grade child, Pippy, by their classmates. Fourth-Grader Identifies Self as “Genderqueer Lesbian” – Prepare to Be Astonished by How This Mother Is Navigating the Situation
Her Gay Ex-husband Wants Her to Give Up His Last Name, but She Refuses – You Won’t Believe Who Had a Problem With It!
A busy mother took to Reddit for opinions after she refused to change her last name just to satisfy her ex-husband. She did make him an offer, though. Her Gay Ex-husband Wants Her to Give Up His Last Name, but She Refuses – You Won’t Believe Who Had a Problem With It!
Investigating Sinclair’s Assertions Regarding Alleged Gay Affairs and Cocaine Use by Obama – Why Hasn’t He Sued for Defamation?
Larry Sinclair has rekindled allegations against former US President Barack Obama, claiming they engaged in gay sexual encounters and cocaine use in 1999. Despite past credibility questions, these allegations have resurfaced, sparking mixed reactions and the hashtag #Obamaisgay trending in the US. Investigating Sinclair’s Assertions Regarding Alleged Gay Affairs and Cocaine Use by Obama – Why Hasn’t He Sued for Defamation?
From “Cannot Bless Sin” to Acceptance: Pope Francis Blesses LGBTQ+ Unions, Sparks Church’s Historic Shift
Pope Francis has extended a groundbreaking olive branch to LGBTQ+ Catholics by expressing his openness to blessing same-sex unions. This monumental shift in the Church’s position represents a significant turning point for LGBTQ+ individuals within the Catholic community. From “Cannot Bless Sin” to Acceptance: Pope Francis Blesses LGBTQ+ Unions, Sparks Church’s Historic Shift
“Distinctly Weird” – Renowned Atheist Richard Dawkins Sparks Controversy With Critique of Transgender Though
In a recent episode of his podcast “The Poetry of Reality,” renowned atheist Richard Dawkins delves into the realm of transgender thought, expressing his skepticism and raising thought-provoking questions. “Distinctly Weird” – Renowned Atheist Richard Dawkins Sparks Controversy With Critique of Transgender Thought
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Yurgentum. The people shown in the images are for illustrative purposes only, not the actual people featured in the story.